Noname Antiques » Antique Buffalo China Value (Identification & Price Guides)

Antique Buffalo China Value (Identification & Price Guides)

The Larkin Soap Company created Tough and durable Buffalo china in the 1900s with the idea to give it to customers purchasing soap. Unfortunately, they ended 102 years of history in 2003, when their offshoot Buffalo Pottery stopped working once and for all.

This pottery was an inexpensive dish type that came in various patterns and colors. People used it in restaurants, hotels, and trains as a part of the railroad china boom. Nowadays, antique Buffalo china is a highly desirable collectible, but you can also use it in everyday life if you prefer that way.

Buffalo Pottery History

Buffalo Pottery History
Image Credit: thesprucecrafts

The Larkin Soap Co. from Buffalo, New York, began producing china and pottery in 1903. That year, the company started its policy of offering customers utensils as a gift when purchasing soap.

While John Durrant Larkin tried to sell soap, salesman Elbert Hubbard developed a marketing plan with a gift-with-purchase concept. That way, they became the first American company to start producing Blue Willow ware. The first Buffalo pottery they designed was semi-vitreous dinnerware sets.

Gaudy Willow line

Soon after, they developed a multi-colored Gaudy Willow line and continued with pottery decorated with game, fish, and fowl.

Special lines

From time to time, the company designed historical and commemorative lines showing George Washington, Roosevelt Bears, and Cinderella. You should set aside at least $1,000 for any of those pieces.

Buffalo pottery manufactured 29 hand-decorated or transfer-printed pitcher varieties with particular patterns from 1905 to 1909. The most popular featured Art Nouveau, Roosevelt Bears, Wild Ducks, Hounds and Stag, Cinderella, and Orchids.

Deldare line

The first company manager Louis H. Bown introduced the Deldare line, the most famous art Buffalo pottery line ever. This olive green pottery type manufactured from 1908 to 1909 represented hand-painted themes.

These pieces contained scenes from popular books, like Cranford and The Vicar of Wakefield. The most popular were dishes decorated with segments from the English village life.

The following year, the company designed candle holders, dinner sets, dresser sets, punch bowls, mugs, pitchers, and vases featuring scenes from the Fallowfield Hunt.

A similar series was produced once again from 1923 to 1925. Interestingly, Deldare Ware has become the most collectible Buffalo pottery until now. Most pieces from this line are inexpensive and typically cost $25 to $100. However, you can find rare collectible items topping the $1,000.

Emerald Deldare line

In 1911, the company introduced the Emerald Deldare pottery line decorated with illustrations from William Combe’s The Three Tours of Dr. Syntax. Nowadays, these humorous pieces are costly and typically reach $1,500.

Abino line

The next step was the rust-colored Abino line inspired by the sea from 1912, featuring scenes of sailboats and windmills. The added artists’ signatures were a crucial novelty. Nowadays, it is challenging to find any Abino pieces, and collectors pay hundreds and even thousands of dollars for an item.

The modern era

The company modernized the manufacturing process in 1915 and started more outstanding vitreous china production. In that period, they were focused on the railroad, restaurant, and hotel orders.

Also Read  Antique Eyeglasses Value (Identification & Price Guides)

However, the fine commercial-grade, home-use china production started in the early 1920s, including the well-known Bluebird pattern.

In 1932, the Chesapeake and Ohio Railroad decided to honor George Washington’s 200th birthday. Therefore, they ordered special china set with President’s portrait and a stylish gold rim from Buffalo pottery.

Even though the company made an unprofitable deal and worked out of a sense of honor and lost money, the calculation paid off later. They got numerous orders for custom china and started producing lines for:

  • Fighter Jack Dempsey’s restaurant in New York
  • Biltmore Hotel in Los Angeles
  • Greenbriar Hotel in West Virginia
  • The Awahnee in Yosemite National Park

The first Christmas plates appeared in 1950 as a gift for employees and customers during the next decade. Nowadays, this line is considered rare, and it is pretty costly.

The Larkin Soap Co. was closed in the 1940s and existed only as a mail-order company for two decades. In 1962, it officially disappeared from the business.

In 1956, the company got the new name, Buffalo China, but soon the Oneida Silver Co. took it over. They still produce commercial-grade pottery for the military, hospitals, restaurants, and clubs.

 

Identifying Buffalo China Marks

You won’t have any problems identifying Buffalo Pottery since this company was one of the few potters in the US to consistently mark their products. Even though the company used various marks during the years, they typically featured an American bison and the date.

consistently mark their products

In most cases, you can also see their name on pottery. Interestingly, the label always included the customer’s name until 1940, making identification even more effortless.

You can notice that the maker’s mark appearance changed over time, but it stayed easily identifiable. In fact, you can quickly date each piece by the logo look.

 

Antique Buffalo China Patterns

The Buffalo company produced a few different china patterns over the years. The list of the most popular variations includes:

Deldare Ware

Deldare Ware

This pattern style included scenes represented in an olive green color. In most cases, they were Cecil Aldin’s drawing reproductions. For instance, the company used numerous sequences from his painting, the Fallowfield Hunt. Particular scenes became a part of famous pottery design, like:

a part of famous pottery design

  • At the Three Pigeons
  • Breakfast at the Three Pigeons
  • The Fallowfield Hunt
  • The Hunt Supper
  • The Dash
  • The Start
  • The Return
  • Breaking Cover
  • The Death

Emerald Deldare

Emerald Deldare

The Emerald Deldare produced in 1911 was a rare Buffalo pottery variation. Since the production lasted only a year, collectors highly appreciate every piece appearing on the market.

This hand-painted design represents classic Art Nouveau style. Besides a verse written inside, you can recognize these pieces by geometric and floral motifs on a beautiful olive green background.

Abino Ware

Abino Ware

The Buffalo company manufactured Abino ware from 1911 to 1913. These rust and pale green-colored pieces typically show sea scenes, boats, and windmills.

Bonrea

Bonrea

This pattern was produced from 1905 to 1916. It typically includes royal blue Asian motifs on a white background.

Statler

Statler

This unique motif contained tan and blue flowers with greenery on a light tan background. It appeared on the market in 1910.

Also Read  Antique China Made in Germany Value (Identification & Price Guides)

Blue willow

Blue willow

The Buffalo company took over an ancient Chinese love story and used this lovely motif to create an American version of the Blue Willow pattern.

This pattern was dedicated to a Chinese legend about a young girl who was in love with a young man. Unfortunately, her father picked out an older man for her betrothed. The betrayed fiancé followed and killed them in revenge. Then, he burned their home to the ground.

Collectors have enjoyed blue and white china pieces for years. Therefore, they appreciate this combination with doves representing young lovers’ souls. Besides these two birds, each Blue Willow piece always contains:

  • Willow trees
  • Boat, pagoda, or teahouse
  • Bridge and latticework fence

Blue bird

Blue bird

The Art Deco style Blue Bird pattern appeared in 1919, and the company produced it until 1922. These pieces are always white with a characteristic blue rim.

Mandalay

Mandalay

Mandalay was an oriental floral pattern on a white background made in 1930. These pieces contained sage green leaves surrounded by flowers in pink, blue, and lavender color.

Chessie cat

Chessie cat

The Chessie Cat pattern from 1933 contained a sleeping tabby cat on the white surface. You can see only its face and ear peeking behind the pillow. It was an order for the Ohio and Chesapeake Railroad.

 

Buffalo China Value

Deldare line is trendy nowadays, and many collectors look for this pottery. Luckily, most ordinary tableware pieces, including mugs and various plates, are affordable, and you can buy one for only $25 to $100.

If you prefer the most quality items with complicated and trendy scenes, you should be prepared that the unique ones can cost up to $1,000 at auctions.

Emerald Deldare is even more appreciated, and you can find these humorous, harder-to-find items for more than $1,500 online. Be prepared that their price is even higher at an East Coast antique show since scarce Buffalo Pottery pieces are in demand there.

Buffalo china value

Buffalo china item Price
Buffalo china Deldare ware mug $712
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt 48 ounces (1.42 l) pitcher $650
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt 32 ounces (0.95 l) pitcher $450
1906 Cinderella Buffalo china pitcher $450
Buffalo china fruit bowl $330
1909 Buffalo china Deldare ware vase $275
Buffalo china Deldare ware vase $250
1914 Buffalo argyle china teapot $250
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt dinner plate $200
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt luncheon plate $170
Buffalo china creamer $170
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt salad plate $160
1909 Buffalo china willow serving bowl $150
Buffalo china Landing of Roger Williams pitcher $150
Buffalo china oval plates $150
Buffalo china water wash jug $115
Buffalo china Cairo pitcher $100
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt mug $100
1916 Buffalo china blue bird butter tub $75
Buffalo china Deldare ware cracked bowl $65.50
Buffalo china Indian tree oval platter $60
Set of three Buffalo china flora of the South railroad ware $49
Four Buffalo china teacups $35
Two buffalo china cappuccino cups $28
Buffalo china blue willow bowl $25
Buffalo china blue willow grill plate $22
Two buffalo china coffee mugs $18
Buffalo china plate $15
Buffalo china blue willow creamer $14
Buffalo china Mandalay creamer $10
Buffalo china Mandalay plate $9
Buffalo china Oneida dinner plate with green edge $8
Also Read  Antique Flatware Value (Identification & Price Guides)

You can find most pitchers for about $400 to $450, while small vases typically reach $200 to $250 on the market. Plates and mugs are pretty common and easy to find, making them inexpensive. In most cases, it will be enough to set aside $10 to $100 for a piece.

Buffalo china Deldare ware mug
Buffalo china Deldare ware mug
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt 48 ounces (1.42 l) pitcher
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt 48 ounces (1.42 l) pitcher
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt 32 ounces (0.95 l) pitcher
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt 32 ounces (0.95 l) pitcher
1906 Cinderella Buffalo china pitcher
1906 Cinderella Buffalo china pitcher
Buffalo china fruit bowl
Buffalo china fruit bowl
1909 Buffalo china Deldare ware vase
1909 Buffalo china Deldare ware vase
Buffalo china Deldare ware vase
Buffalo china Deldare ware vase
1914 Buffalo argyle china teapot
1914 Buffalo argyle china teapot
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt dinner plate
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt dinner plate
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt luncheon plate
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt luncheon plate
Buffalo china creamer
Buffalo china creamer
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt salad plate
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt salad plate
1909 Buffalo china willow serving bowl
1909 Buffalo china willow serving bowl
Buffalo china Landing of Roger Williams pitcher
Buffalo china Landing of Roger Williams pitcher
Buffalo china oval plates
Buffalo china oval plates
Buffalo china water wash jug
Buffalo china water wash jug
Buffalo china Cairo pitcher
Buffalo china Cairo pitcher
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt mug
Buffalo china Fallowfield hunt mug
1916 Buffalo china blue bird butter tub
1916 Buffalo china blue bird butter tub
Buffalo china Deldare ware cracked bowl
Buffalo china Deldare ware cracked bowl
Buffalo china Indian tree oval platter
Buffalo china Indian tree oval platter
Set of three Buffalo china flora of the South railroad ware
Set of three Buffalo china flora of the South railroad ware
Four Buffalo china teacups
Four Buffalo china teacups
Two buffalo china cappuccino cups
Two buffalo china cappuccino cups
Buffalo china blue willow bowl
Buffalo china blue willow bowl
Buffalo china blue willow grill plate
Buffalo china blue willow grill plate
Two buffalo china coffee mugs
Two buffalo china coffee mugs
Buffalo china plate
Buffalo china plate
Buffalo china blue willow creamer
Buffalo china blue willow creamer
Buffalo china Mandalay creamer
Buffalo china Mandalay creamer
Buffalo china Mandalay plate
Buffalo china Mandalay plate
Buffalo china Oneida dinner plate with green edge
Buffalo china Oneida dinner plate with green edge

 

Places to Find Buffalo Pottery

Buffalo pottery is widely available on the market, and you can find most pieces in different patterns effortlessly. Even though these dishes are typically inexpensive, you can discover that prices significantly vary, depending on the selling place.

Online sale websites

As always, you can find this pottery type on the Net. Popular selling sites, like eBay, Etsy, and Amazon, are unlimited sources of collectible Buffalo china. Learning to recognize desired pieces from the company’s different lines is necessary before picking out those you have chosen to collect.

An East Coast antique show

It is the place for the most dedicated Buffalo pottery collectors who look for the rarest and most expensive pieces. You can find an extensive selection there, but be aware that most items will be more costly there than elsewhere.

 

Create Your Own Collection

Over a century-old Buffalo pottery is an excellent option for any home, and it is unlikely for those utensils to go out of style. That is a probable reason for most collectors to start looking for these beautiful pieces and valuable parts of American history.

The best part is that you can create your collection on your own, without any imposed rules. Since there are a few different lines, you should pick out the one you like the most and start your new collection.

Nowadays, it is possible to find numerous items online and buy them separately at an affordable price. For instance, you can purchase dinner and salad plates, soup bowls, and mugs with the same motif separately or in sets.

Keep in mind that serving platters, egg cups, and pitchers are less known but valuable additions to every collection. Nowadays, children’s sets can be worthy, particularly rare ones.

There is one more thing! Unlike other pottery, Buffalo china pieces are highly durable, and you can collect and use them in everyday life. They are difficult to break, making them practical. Plus, finding a replacement is not a problem if an accident occurs.

 

Summary

The Buffalo Pottery Co. was established in 1901 in New York as a Larkin Soap Company offshoot. The goal was to create dishes to increase soap purchases.

Those dishes were excellent and inexpensive options for hotels, restaurants, and railroad dining cars in the past. Nowadays, Buffalo pottery is appreciated collectibles that come in many patterns and colors.

Leave a Comment